Choose Your Own Adventure

Thursday, April 29

Read R.D. Pohl On the New York Times Book Review of Charles Bernstein's All the Whiskey in Heaven


By R.D. Pohl for the Buffalo News Artsbeat:
If there remained any doubt that "Language writing"--once the scourge of the sclerotic "Official Verse Culture" and mainstream literary media in the United States that it sought to critique--is now the dominant linguistic frame through which literary innovation is parsed, last week's laudatory New York Times Book Review of Charles Bernstein's All The Whiskey in Heaven: Selected Poems (Farrar, Straus & Giroux) convincingly puts it to rest.

If the occasion of the review is Bernstein's first volume of poems "not published by a university or independent press," what reviewer Daisy Fried writes about the former University at Buffalo professor and co-founder of the UB Poetics program ("famous as a poet and anti-poet") is a kind of performative utterance:

With “All the Whiskey in Heaven,” ...Bernstein takes his place in the mainstream of American poetry, the very “Official Verse Culture” he’s attacked entertainingly for years — a fate awaiting all our best outsiders. Bernstein is identified with the Language poets, who emerged in the 1970s. Interested in the materiality of language, they are politically left, theoretically grounded and deeply suspicious of the lyric “I” that speaks from the heart in traditional poems without examining its own existence in a sociopolitical power structure.

If the New York Times Book Review, ostensibly the house organ of the "Official Verse Culture" in the United States proclaims it, it must necessarily be a fait accompli. Never mind that All the Whiskey in Heaven is the first of Bernstein's sixteen full length collections of poetry and five books of essays over the past three decades ever to earn a New York Times review. Never before has the ascent from persona non grata to literary icon been accomplished with such selective hindsight.

In the current (Spring 2010) issue of BOMB Magazine Bernstein is interviewed by journalist Jay Sanders on the origins of L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E magazine (the title for which Bernstein attributes to co-founder Bruce Andrews), the various misconceptions that arose about language writing, and its influence on a broad range of 21st century poetics. In response to a question from Sanders about the perceived "militant aesthetic break" from prevailing poetic practice that the procedural and constraint-based techniques of language writing is thought to have represented, Bernstein avers:

When we started L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E we were trying to open up conversations across divides. As you say, rather than trying to narrow things down, the journal was about dialogue not just among poets of the same generation and the same perspective, but among poets of different generations, and also with those in the other arts. Still, the reaction in terms of the parochial world of poetry was that somehow something exclusive was being launched. We proposed an alternative to what then dominated as respectable poetry. Ours was a poetics of (some of) the excluded....

...We tried to trace a history of radical poetics, taking up the model presented in Jerome Rothenberg’s Revolution of the Word, and later by Rothenberg and Pierre Joris in Poems for the Millennium and Marjorie Perloff in The Futurist Moment. When you go back 30 years, you see that poetics that now are widely accepted as foundational for contemporary poetry were harshly rejected then. Poetry’s center of gravity has shifted to the poetic left, to call it that, though not everyone has heard the news. Even in the more mainstream poetry magazines now there’s a certain amount of work that is far looser and formally radical than you would have seen in the mid-’70s.

Asked about to what extent he and peers contributed to an "opening of the field" (Robert Duncan's phrase) for innovation, Bernstein points out that "...some recent poetry and poetics concertedly take out the contentiousness from formal invention." Discussing the 2009 Norton American Hybrid poetry anthology, he observes that "while the editors welcome a certain kind of elliptical, fragmented style, they also try to find a happy mean between extremes."

It's what he says next that speaks to the lasting influence of Language writing on 21st century poetics:

For me, it’s the extremity, the eccentricity, even the didacticism, that shakes things up. When poetry becomes normalized and more oriented toward craft, it loses the point. I’m not interested in any of the styles, per se, that were developed in the ’70s and ’80s—my own or anybody else’s. The issue was never stylistic technique as such. You have to read that era in the context of the intense resistance to nonlinear poetry, to algorithmic forms, to appropriated language, and non-“I”-centered poems—all of which are now accepted. Even the procedural is just one technique or form that emerges, sometimes zombie-like, to reveal hidden codes, or other times just as textile, as generator of texture.

In this sense, it's not the "mainstream" of American poetry that Bernstein and Armantrout have entered; it's the river itself that has changed its course.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Blog Archive

Family and Friends

(At Sea) (1) (N(007)DLES (1) 23 (1) 28 Degrees Taurus (1) A Hotel Nourishing (2) A Relative Term (1) A Storm of Light (1) Aaron Miller (1) ABCDJ (1) Acid Mothers Temple (1) Adam Deitch (1) Adultnapper (1) AIDS Wolf (2) Ajent O (1) Aki Onda (2) Akron/Family (2) Al Larsen (3) Album Leaf (1) Alfred Brown (1) All Them Witches (3) Aloha (1) Amber Long (2) Amungus (1) An Horse (1) Andrew Barker (1) Andrew Bird (4) Andrew Duetsch (4) Andy Rourke (1) Animal Collective (15) Apples in the Stereo (1) Arehouse (4) Ariel Pink (10) Arizona Drains (2) Arrington de Dionyso (4) ART/IMPROV (122) Arthur Doyle Electro-Acoustic Ensemble (1) Ashley Paul (2) Asobi Seksu (2) At Sea (2) Atomic (1) Audrey Chen (2) AVANT-INDIE (316) Ay Fast (2) Baby Dee (1) Bare Flames (5) Barry Weisblatt (1) Battles (5) Bear in Heaven (2) Bearhunter (1) Beige Records (1) Bernice Marie (1) Besnard Lakes (1) Besnyo (6) Beta Cloud (1) Bev Beverly (4) Big Basha (10) Big Digits (1) Big Gigantic (3) Big Orbit Gallery (1) Bill Horist (1) Bill Nace (4) Bill Sack (1) Biodeisel (1) Bird Day (2) Black Bloc (1) Black Moth Super Rainbow (5) Black Umbrella (1) Blessed Sacrifist (1) Blockhead (2) Blue Cheer (2) Blue Collar (2) Blueprint (2) Bobby Birdman (2) Boris (3) Born Heller (1) Brandon Stosuy (1) Break Science (1) Brett Masteller (1) Brian Milbrand (3) Brian Wheat (1) Brightblack Morninglight (1) Buffalo Soundpainting Ensemble (1) Bufffluxus (3) Burning Star Core (2) Burnt Sugar The Arkestra Chamber (1) Busdriver (1) C-Mon (1) C. Spencer Yeh (2) C3PO (2) Cages (3) Call of the Wild (1) Calvin Johnson (2) Capillary Action (1) Caribou (2) Castanets (1) Caustic Solution (5) Cex (2) Chad Taylor (4) Chae Hawk (3) Chain and the Gang (1) Charles Bernstein (1) Charles Clough (1) Charles Gayle (1) Charles Olson (1) Charlie Looker (2) Chiara Giovando (1) Chicago Underground Duo (1) Chris Borkowski (1) Chris Coleman (2) Chris Corsano (4) Chris Forsyth (1) Chris Forsythe (2) Christian Bök (1) Chugga Chugga (2) Chylde (3) Cindy Sherman (2) Circuit Circus (1) Clicks and Whistles (1) Clogs (7) Clovers (1) Coffee (2) Colin Beatty (2) Com Truise (1) Communication Hymns (1) Communist Party (20) Computer Club (1) Cor Fuhler (2) Cort Lippe (4) Cory Arcangel (3) Cotton Jones (1) Craig Smith (2) Creative Associates (1) Critical Art Ensemble (4) Cults (1) D.U.G.O.U.T.C.A.N.O.E. (1) Dan Deacon (12) Daniel Carter (1) Daniel Higgs (1) Darin Gray (1) Dark Party (1) Daughters (3) David Andree (1) David Daniell (1) Dear Families (1) Deerhoof (5) Deerhunter (5) Dennis Cooper (1) Derek Holzer (1) Diplo (6) Dirty on Purpose (1) Dirty Projectors (26) DJ Bacon (1) DJ Brandon Chase (1) Dj D-Star (2) DJ Dave G (2) Dj Dopestar (2) DJ Jake Gittes (1) DJ K Gunz (1) DJ MJB Corporation (3) DJ Olive (5) DJ Sniff (1) DJ Soma (1) DJ Spooky (4) DJ Trio (1) Do Make Say Think (2) Don Metz (1) Doomriders (1) Dosh (1) Dudley Ghost (1) Dum Dum Girls (2) Ecstatic Sunshine (2) Eileen Myles (1) Elephant 6 (1) Elf Power (1) Eli Keszler (2) Eliot Lipp (1) Elliot Sharp (1) Eluvium (1) Emancipator (2) Enon (1) Entrance (3) Erik Friedlander (2) Erotic Economies (1) Eskmo (3) Espers (1) Essentialist (3) Eulipion (1) Excusamwa (1) Extra Life (3) Fang Island (1) Fat Worm of Error (1) Fatal Figures (1) Felix Cartal (1) Floor (1) Flufftronix (1) Fly Pan Am (1) Fog (1) Foot and Mouth Disease (1) Foreign Born (2) Fourem (7) Fourem/Rainbowmaker (2) Free Energy (6) From Monuments to Masses (2) Fruit Bats (2) Future Rock (1) G Lucas Crane (3) Gary Nickard (3) Gaslamp Killer (4) Gebhard Ullman (1) Genghis Tron (1) Gerard O'Grady (2) Gerry Hemingway (1) Ghengis Tron (1) Girl Talk (3) Glenn Hall (1) Glenn Jones (4) Glenn Kotche (1) Golden Dawn Trio (1) Gong For Brums (1) Gordon Beeferman (1) Greg Davis (1) Gregg Bendian (1) Grizzly Bear (6) Grouper (1) Guitar Trio (3) Gull (1) Gut Flora (1) Hamid Drake (1) Handsome Furs (4) Health and Beauty (1) Height with Bow (2) Here Come the Comets (1) High Places (9) Ho-ag (5) Holis Frampton (1) Hollis Frampton (6) Holy Fuck (2) Holy Sheet (1) Hot Pink Delorian (1) Hush Arbors (3) Huxley (3) Hymns (1) I Heart Lung (1) Ian MacKaye (2) Ian Svenonius (1) Icy Demons (1) In Tall Buildings (1) Intension Quintet (1) Interzone (1) Iran (1) Islands (3) It Smells Like Laundry (1) J Mascis (3) Jack Rose (4) Jack Topht with the Vegetables (1) Jack Wright (1) Jameel Moondoc (1) James Blackshaw (3) James Blue (2) James Plotkin (1) James Toth (2) Jan Williams (2) Japandroids (3) Jason Ajemian (1) Jason Forrest (1) Jax Deluca (3) Jeff Arnal (1) Jemeel Moondoc (1) Jeph Jerman (1) Jeremy Jay (3) Jessica Pavone (4) Jessica Thompson (1) Jim Abramson (1) Joe Nice (1) Joe Rozler (2) John Bacon (4) John Butcher (1) John Long (3) John McEntire (1) John Nystrom (1) John Valenti (1) Johnny Nobody (1) Jonathan Golove (4) Jooklo Duo (1) Josephine Foster (3) Josh Abrams (3) Josh Strauss (1) Josh the Funky 1 (1) JT Rinker (4) Julian Montague (3) Junior Boys (4) K-Holes (1) Kayo Dot (2) Keir Neuringer (3) Kermit Driscol (1) Kevin Barker (1) KG Price (1) Knife Crazy (1) Knife Jesus (1) Knife World (1) Knowmatic Tribe (7) Knox Harrington (2) Koji Tambata (2) Kralice (1) Kyle Price (6) Kypski (1) Lali Puna (1) Laundry Room Squelchers (1) Lavender (1) Leah Muir (1) Leah Rico (1) Lechuguillas (1) Lee Ranaldo (2) Leif Nicklas (2) Lejaren Hiller (2) Leo123 (1) Leslie Fiedler (1) Lichens (4) Lightning Bolt (1) Lights (2) Little People (1) Little Women (1) Liturgy (1) Loki (1) Lovely Feather (1) Lukas Foss (1) Lulldozer (3) Luvstep (2) Lymbyc Systm (1) Mad Love (1) Magic Markers (5) Mahjongg (1) Malaikat Dan Singa (1) Malaria Control (1) Mallwalkers (1) MAP (2) Margot and the Nuclear So and Sos (1) Marina Rosenfeld (4) Mario Bee (7) Marissa Nadler (1) Mark Freeland (2) Mark Kloud (9) Mark Nosowicz (1) Mark Webb (5) Marnie Stern (1) Mary Halvorson (4) Matana Roberts (2) Matt and Kim (5) Matthew Heyner (1) Mattin (6) Mayo Thompson (1) Medison (3) Melt Banana (1) Mercury Club (1) Mersault (1) Metalux (3) Mia Doi Todd (6) Michael Allard (1) Michael Basinski (4) Michael Hermanson (1) Michel Doneda (1) Michelle Tea (1) Mick Turner (4) Mike Ladd (1) Mike Parker (2) Miles Benjamin Anthony Robinson (1) Millie Chen (1) MMCIII (1) Mock Syringa (2) Mon Petite Chou Chou (1) Mono (3) Monotonix (2) Morton Feldman (6) Mount Eerie (3) Mountains (4) Mr Lif (3) Mt St Helen's Vietnam Band (3) MULTI-MEDIA (86) MUTANT BEATS (120) Mutus Liber (2) Mux Mool (2) MV and EE (2) My Brightest Diamond (5) N3wT (1) Nadja (1) Nat Baldwin (12) Natasha Kmeto (1) Nate Wooley (5) Natural Ingredients (1) Needel (4) Nels Cline (1) Neon Indian (7) Neptune (2) Neutral Milk Hotel (1) Newton Armstrong (2) Ninjasonik (4) Nobody Beats the Drum (1) Noel Kupersmith (1) Nola Ranallo (6) NOMO (1) Normal Love (1) Novelist (2) NSFW (3) Nuuj (1) NY Sexy Beast (1) Octopus Project (5) ODDS N SODS (70) Of Montreal (1) Okkervil River (1) Old Time Relijun (3) Olivia Tremor Control (1) On Beta (2) On Fillmore (1) One Be Lo (2) Onedia (2) Oneida (3) Oriental Rugs (1) Orodruin (1) Oxford Collective (1) P.G. Six (1) Pacing (2) Pam Swarts (1) Pamela Susan Hawkins (1) Pan American (1) Paper rad (3) Papercuts (1) Papi Chulo (1) Parts and Labor (5) Patrick Cain (1) Pattern is Movement (2) Paul Devro (2) Paul Flaherty (4) Paul Kozlowski (4) Paul Sharits (8) Paul Vanouse (1) Paul's Grandfather (1) Peanut Brittle Satellite (2) Peeesseye (1) Peer Bode (1) Pengo (4) Perceptor (2) Peter B (2) Peter Bonk (1) Peter Brötzmann (1) Peter Hook (3) Peter Walker (4) Peter Weibel (1) Phantogram (3) Phil Elverum (3) Phosphorescent (1) Picastro (2) Plants and Animals (1) Pnuma Trio (1) Point Juncture (2) Polmo Popo (3) Pomegranates (1) Poverty Hymns (4) Power Pill Fist (1) Prairies (2) Praying for Oblivion (2) Prefuse 73 (6) Privacy (3) Radian (1) Rara Avis (1) Ravi Padmanaba (7) Raymond Federman (5) Readybox (1) Red Krayola (3) Red Sparrowes (3) Red Tag Rummage Sale (3) Reece Q (1) Reid Speed (1) Reinhard Reitzenstein (1) Rhys Chatham (5) Ric Royer (3) Ringo Brill (1) RJD2 (4) Rob Mazurek (1) Rob Sonic (4) Robert Creeley (1) Robert Dick (1) Robert Longo (1) Roboroc (1) Roger Bryan and the Orphans (2) Ron Ehmke (1) Royal Bangs (1) Rrrump (1) Rural Alberta Advantage (1) Rusko (5) RX (2) Sabir Mateen (2) Saviours (1) Scott Valkwitch (1) Sean Meehan (2) Seductive Sprigs (1) Seth Misterka (1) Shaky Hands (2) shapes of states (2) Shelley Burgon (2) Shigeto (2) Shilpa Ray and Her Happy Hookers (1) Shock and Awe (13) shout out out out out (1) Siew-Wai Kok (2) Singer (1) Sir Richard Bishop (1) Six Organs of Admittance (5) Skeletons and the Kings of All Cities (1) Skoal Kodiak (1) Sleeping Future (1) Sleeping Kings of Iona (7) Smash Gordon (1) Snackboy (2) Soft Circle (11) Sole (1) Soul Position (2) Speakerfire (1) Spider Goat (1) Stay Lows (4) Steina and Woody Vasulka (1) Stephen Prina (1) Steve Baczkowski (22) Steve Kream (3) Steve Swell (4) Sticks and Stones (2) Styrofoam (1) Suckers (1) Sugar City (1) Sunburned Hand of the Man (7) Sunn O)))) (4) Sunset Rubdown (2) Superwow (1) Surfer Blood (3) Taku Anami (1) Tape (2) Tassels from a Day Sale (1) Tatsuya Nakatani (6) Team Robespierre (2) Teen Heat (1) Tentet/Octet (2) Tera Melos (1) Terror Pigeon Dance Revolt (3) Terry Riley (3) The American Dream Team (1) The Art Department (1) The Auras (1) The Bear Exchange (2) The Books (3) The Chandeliers (1) The cinnamon Band (3) The Entrance Band (4) The Evens (2) The Go Find (1) The Hive Dwellers (1) The Lochs (3) The Microphones (2) The Murder Group (1) The Music Tapes (4) The Narcs (1) The National (9) The Perceptionists (2) The Polish Ambassador (1) The Runway (1) The Shakes (1) The Spits (1) The Thermals (5) The Thermidors (1) The Voidologists (3) The Vores (3) Thee Donnie Shaft (2) Thee Silver Mt Zion Memorial Orchestra (5) This is the Sun (1) Tiger Hatchery (1) Tim Barnes (6) Times New Viking (1) Todd Reynolds (3) Todd Whitman (1) TOKiMONSTA (2) Tokyo Police Club (1) Tom Abbs (1) Tom Holt (1) Tom Watson (1) Tony Conrad (14) Tortoise (1) toshimuara Nakamura (1) Toshio Kajiwara (4) Treelined Highway (1) Trevor Dunn (2) Tristan Trump (5) Tumul (1) Turbo Fruits (2) TV Ghost (1) Tweek (1) Tweeknasty (1) Tyondai Braxton (5) Type Relevant (1) UB (1) Una Slim (1) US Girls (1) USAISAMONSTER (3) Utah Jazz (2) UVB-76 (1) Vacant Lots (1) Vampire Belt (1) Vampire Weekend (18) Versoma (2) Vetiver (1) Via Audio (1) Video Hippos (1) VJ Deliria (1) Voices Voices (2) Voltage (3) Voulez Vous Danser Avec Moi (1) VWLS (2) w ((aa)) ou w (3) WA (1) Warmer Milks (3) Warren Quigley (1) White Fang (1) Why? (13) Wiliam Parker (1) William Hooker (2) William Parker (4) Wind Up Bird (8) Witch (2) Wolf Eyes (2) Wolves in the Throne Room (1) Wooden Hand (2) Wooden Wand and The Vanishing Voice (1) Wooden Wand the Vanishing Voice (2) Wooden Wav (1) Wooden Waves (5) Woods (3) World's End Girlfriend (2) Worrywort (1) Xiu Xiu (2) Yacht (21) Yellow Swans (1) Yip Yip (1) Young Galaxy (1) Z Mann Zilla (1) Zaimph (1) Zs (3)

Followers